This is in continuation of my article Eliminate the Tax Scam. The only way to solve the problem of runaway central power is take the one thing needed to support power, the right to collect taxes from the masses. The central government can force individuals at gun point to pay any amount of taxes they decide appropriate. I believe that gun would have less effect on state government.
I believe this is something people of all political persuasions might like. This doesn't eliminate many things the progressives like. A progressive state would be free to operate as they always have. This also goes for libertarian and conservative leaning states. If this country is to survive as a whole, power must be taken away from the central government.
Some are talking about opening an Article IV Constitutional convention. If states are to take that route, the 16th and 17th Amendments are at the top of the list to be repealed. I'm not sure that enough states would agree with the repeal of those amendments. I do believe that if the 16th is repealed with my 31st Amendment, then more states might be agreeable.
Eliminate the Tax Scam
This is my original article that led to the Freedom Tax

Each year we watch a parade of politicians promising us everything in order to gain our vote. We know that most of these promises will never be fulfilled. We also know that they will blame those failed promises on the other party. I am here to talk about the promises they do keep.

We have amassed a $16.5 trillion dollar debt. We have some telling us that the debt doesn't matter. I m told it won't matter until we reach $20 trillion. At the rate of debt growth we can see this happening in at least four years. We have one side telling us that we need to stimulate the economy. We have the other side spending more and wanting to raise taxes on the rich. That same side also tells us that we need to stop subsidizing certain industries, while increasing subsidies for others. For those who are unclear, a subsidy is no more than a tax exemption on certain aspect of that business. This is done to move the businesses in certain directions.

Now let's talk about the most important aspect of tax exemptions. It has gotten to the point that it requires at least $1 billion to run for president; millions to run for lesser offices. Where do they get this money? Yes, you are right, they get it from special interest. Once in office this special interest expects something in return. It is illegal for an elected official to give favors for donations, but they do. That favor usually comes in the form of a regulation that might harm a competitor, or more likely it comes in the form of a tax exemptions. No matter if you vote democrat or republican you are aware of this.

We ask, if everyone is aware, why do they let it continue? People don't want it to stop because the government bribes them with housing subsidies. Each year the biggest tax deduction for a family is the house mortgage. This subsidy isn't just for the people, government isn't that caring. They also subsidize the housing industry just like they do most other industries. What people don't realize is that deduction is figured into the value of the house. If that deduction was removed the value would soon drop to come in line with the market evaluation.

Those on the left and right fervently fight a flat tax or a national sales tax. I suspect this is because many don't want to give up their home or business subsidy. I won't chide you for accepting exactly what you hate the politicians for giving to mega corporations. What I will do is offer an alternative. I propose that we allow only states to collect taxes. A person or industry would never pay federal taxes again. The state would then become solely responsible for all federal taxes.

As it is today we, the individual or corporation, sends money directly to the federal government. They then decide what portion will be sent back to the state in the form of grants for roads and schools. The problem lies in the fact that money always comes with strings attached. The federal government has a long history of using that money in blackmail fashion to control everything from illegal drugs, schools, and speed limits.

If all taxes were paid to the state, then the federal government would have to negotiate how much each state sends to them. I would assume there would be a flat base rate to insure the funding of our military and other services, while all other monies would come through negotiation and need.

This would completely eliminate the IRS, and that alone would be a huge savings. Of course the states would have to expand their tax collection agencies. This would be no huge burden because the state would have extra money. Some states might not have to increase the size of their tax collection agency because it would already be sufficient. Some states might choose to have a flat tax that would even reduce the size of those agencies.

Paying taxes to a single entity would greatly reduce cost for individuals and businesses. Those savings would be realized in goods and services we buy. This would also take away power from federally elected officials. It is easy to bribe one congress person to amend a bill with a tax exemption. It would be much harder to bribe legislators in every state. Money is power, and the only way we can possibly take the power out of Washington is to take their money. The federal government would find it far more difficult to strong-arm states for more money as they can so easily do with the individual.

It's time we stop using the same old playbook. We have to start thinking outside the box. We must find solutions that would make those on the right, and those who are moderately left happy. This is not the perfect plan, but it's at least different and could be a start. If nothing else it would make tax collection more efficient.


Passed by Congress July 2, 1909. Ratified February 3, 1913.

Note: Article I, section 9, of the Constitution was modified by amendment 16.
The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

Article 1 Section 9

No Capitation, or other direct, Tax shall be laid, unless in Proportion to the Census or enumeration herein before directed to be taken.

There is nothing in the Constitution that states the federal government must collect income taxes directly from individual, only that they can. The 16th Amendment could be a stumbling block to this proposal, but it doesn't have to be.

Views: 38

Comment by Jerseygal on December 15, 2013 at 10:35am

Good post, TLC!  Sharing on Twitter!

Comment by Robin on December 16, 2013 at 10:27am

Outstanding post! I am all for getting rid of the IRS! Flat tax or consumption tax! Having only the states collect taxes as well is a great idea!  It would stop Washington from using tax monies as leverage to bribe and intimidate!  It would halt the out of control spending in it's tracks! Tweeting this out! 

Comment by TLC on December 16, 2013 at 11:05am

The best part, the federal government cannot withhold funding in an effort to control states. Also states and have whatever taxing system the people want, such as Fair Tax. The Freedom Tax is a work in progress. I'm sure it can be tweaked in certain areas.

Yes, it would force the federal government to budget. It would work even better if there was no federal reserve, but that's a different battle for a different day. I see no other way to take power from the federal government other  than by the brute force of an Amendment.

By the time progressives get through with the Fair Tax it will still be very progressive. It's going to take drastic measures to get the power out of DC.

Comment by TLC on December 16, 2013 at 11:09am

One thing I might would add to the amendment is that the federal government cannot tax citizens directly.


You need to be a member of Fundamental Refounding to add comments!

Join Fundamental Refounding




Please view our mission, policy, and legal disclaimer to learn about us by visiting the main menu.  Thank you.




Let your voice be counted!








national debt

Founders' Corner

Latest Activity

Jerome replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion Wed Tids 7/29/20 TOP TID We're Seeing the Death Rattle of the Revolution, Not Its Birth
"I agree with much of this post.  However, the title troubles me. "This is the Death…"
Jul 30
Robin replied to Jodi180's discussion STOP THE COVID-19 TRACE ACT H.R. 6666 TELL TRUMP TO VETO IT
"EXCLUSIVE: Bill Gates Negotiated $100 Billion Contact Tracing Deal With Democratic Congressman…"
Jul 29
Robin replied to Robin's discussion White House Puts Out Statement Going After Fauci’s Credibility
"EXCLUSIVE: Bill Gates Negotiated $100 Billion Contact Tracing Deal With Democratic Congressman…"
Jul 29
Robin replied to Doug Fox's discussion Traitor's Justice
"Federal judge orders secret Ghislaine Maxwell documents to begin being unsealed A federal judge on…"
Jul 29
Robin posted a discussion

Justice Department.. Operation Legend Expanded to Cleveland, Detroit, and Milwaukee

Law and Order President!Department of Justice Office of Public Affairs FOR IMMEDIATE…See More
Jul 29
Fundamental Refounding posted discussions
Jul 29
Jodi180 replied to Jodi180's discussion STOP THE COVID-19 TRACE ACT H.R. 6666 TELL TRUMP TO VETO IT
"Family Under House Arrest After Testing Positive for COVID-19 I just recently received news of a…"
Jul 24
Robin replied to Doug Fox's discussion Traitor's Justice
"VIDEO Karli Q Medium r @KarluskaP Central Casting featuring John Durham JR. ?…"
Jul 16
Robin replied to Doug Fox's discussion Traitor's Justice
"Lots getting ready to come out! Antonio Sabáto Jr @AntonioSabatoJr The truth of the…"
Jul 16
Fundamental Refounding replied to Jodi180's discussion No One's Coming to Save America...We Must Save Ourselves
"America is awake! We have to make sure Trump wins or it is over. Biden gets crazier by the day.…"
Jul 16
Fundamental Refounding replied to Watchman's discussion How the man who eradicated smallpox would have handled coronavirus
"I agree with JG. This was not handled right from the start! The lockdown has had far worse…"
Jul 16
Fundamental Refounding posted a discussion

Trump Promises Announcement Next Week on Democrat-Run Cities: 'We're Going to Straighten Things Out'

( - When it comes to crime, some of America's Democrat-run cities are "out of control,"…See More
Jul 16
Robin replied to Robin's discussion White House Puts Out Statement Going After Fauci’s Credibility
"I agree Watchman! He in so deep with Gates, it's disgusting."
Jul 16
Watchman replied to Robin's discussion White House Puts Out Statement Going After Fauci’s Credibility
"I never liked Fauci from the beginning. There was something about him that rubbed me the wrong way."
Jul 12
Robin posted a discussion

White House Puts Out Statement Going After Fauci’s Credibility

The only reason Fauci was on this from the beginning is, he is head of the NIH! They had to have…See More
Jul 12
Jerseygal liked Jodi180's discussion No One's Coming to Save America...We Must Save Ourselves
Jul 12

© 2020   Fundamental Refounding.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service