10 reasons to NOT shutdown the economy over the coronavirus

10 reasons why I think shutting down the economy, businesses, and mass quarantines are not only unwarranted, but ultimately destructive:

1) The longer this goes on the more damage it does to our economy, possibly leading to a recession or a depression. The economy is our life-blood. If the economy collapses then the health system collapses, and more people will die. 

2) It infringes on our Constitutional rights to freely assemble, and can easily be abused by the governing authorities to enact even more draconian and unconstitutional measures. 

3) There is no guarantee the current approach of “shelter-in-place” and “social distancing” will completely halt the spread of the virus, and even if it does there is no guarantee the virus won't come back again next year. We can’t afford to repeat this process again. It is untenable, unsustainable, and ultimately damaging to the economy. This virus may be here to stay and we must learn to live with it like all the other myriad of viruses and diseases we already live with.

4) The current approach is unprecedented and the consequences are unknown. We didn't shut down the economy and quarantine the populace during the 2002 SARS outbreak, 2009 bird flu outbreak or the 2014-2016 Ebola outbreak. 

5) There are other alternatives. South Korea, among other Asian countries, are fighting the virus using widespread testing and quarantining only the sick, while keeping their society free and open. Why are we following the Chinese model and not the South Korean model? 

6) Mortality rates don't give the complete picture. They are not static but can vary from one location to another, and are effected by contributing factors. Even the mortality rate of the common flu can be as high as 8% among certain demographics, such as in nursing homes. 

7) We are not Italy nor Wuhan. China has wet markets (breeding grounds for viruses), heavy pollution, high population, and are heavy smokers, all of which contributed to their high mortality rate. Likewise, Italy has the second oldest population in the world, has socialized medicine, they greet each other with a kiss on the cheek, and have direct ties with China though the One Belt and One Road initiative.

8) It's an over-reaction. During the 2017-2018 flu season, the CDC stated that 80,000 died during the 2017/2018 US flu season. The economy was not shut down and nobody panicked. 

9) So far it has not been worse than the flu. The typical flu season starts in October\November in North America. As of December 27th 2019, it was reported there were 2,100 deaths from the flu. The first case of CV-19 in the US was January 19th 2020, and as of March 21st there were 300 deaths from the CV-19 virus in the US. That means that 2,100 died from the flu versus 300 from CV-19 in roughly the same period of time.

10) It has a 97-98% survival rate and mostly affects the elderly who have underlying health issues. The latter group is already at high risk every flu season. Symptoms may vary from mild to severe to not showing any symptoms at all, again much like the flu.

The CV-19 outbreak onboard the Diamond Princess Cruise ship is for me the best example why I don’t think the CV-19 virus is anything extraordinary or something to worry about.  The Diamond Princess was the ultimate petri dish. It was a closed environment in which all the passengers and crew were tested. The mortality rate was only 1%, and this with the majority of the passengers being 60 and over. There are two things we can gleam from this: 1) 1% is far less than the global mortality rate of 3.4%, and 2) it would have likely been even lower with a more diverse age group.

Views: 75

Comment by Watchman on March 27, 2020 at 1:01am

More stats:

Between October 1, 2019, and December 7, 2019, there have been up to 3.7 million cases of the flu, between 23,000 to 41,000 hospitalizations, and approximately 1,300 to 3,300 flu-related deaths, according to the CDC. https://www.healthline.com/...

Between January 19th and March 26th, 2020 there have been 82,404 cases of Covid-19 and a little over 1,000 deaths in the US.

Tell me again why we are destroying our economy?

Comment by Lynn Rackoski on April 4, 2020 at 6:30pm

I too am very concerned that if this goes on much longer, we will be in a recession and can quickly go into a depression! Everyone try to keep money out of the bank in case there is a run on the banks!

Comment by J. Francis Roth on April 5, 2020 at 2:16pm

This is not an accident, this is an effort by the Leftist Globalists to bring the U.S. to it's knees.  Overwhelm the system, ruin the most robust economy the world has ever seen.  Destroy the Republic and the President of the Republic.  Only if this things are accomplish can the global left "fundamentally transform the United States" into a third world nation where all people are equal (right), equally poor, equally hungry, equally living in squalor.  The Virus is real, the forced mitigation has an agenda, and it's all leftist.  Someone besides me and Barack Obama had to read "RULES FOR RADICALS" By Saul Alinsky, it's all in there.  Plus, someone tell me why Dr. Fauci is now the President and Dr. Birx is the Vice President.  Someone tell me how Dr. Fauci and Bill Gates, both globalists, both Leftists knew and predicted back in 2017 the Donald Trump would be faced with a SURPRISE PANDEMIC!!!  These leftists will continue to push this shutdown until the United States Republic is no more, unless of course President Trump opens our economy asap.  

Comment by Watchman on April 5, 2020 at 2:50pm

I'm not completely certain this is some grand conspiracy. Much of what has happened is governors and mayors deciding on their own to shut everything down. It wasn't really a concerted effort and it's the same with countries as well. I see panic and fear has being the driving force in all this. But one thing is for certain, the globalist types are taking full advantage of it and we need to be very careful. We are in a very precarious place right now.

Comment

You need to be a member of Fundamental Refounding to add comments!

Join Fundamental Refounding

Attention:

 

 

Please view our mission, policy, and legal disclaimer to learn about us by visiting the main menu.  Thank you.

PLEASE SIGN THE PETITION!

BRING BACK #HUAC

http://bit.ly/2mqIVmH 

CONTACT CONGRESS!

Let your voice be counted!

House:  http://1.usa.gov/mHZjgo

Senate:  http://1.usa.gov/3UAs

 

 

PLEASE PRAY FOR OUR NATION.

 

 

national debt

Founders' Corner

Latest Activity

kwicgov55 replied to Robin's discussion UPDATE On Things At My Home and my being absent! Ref: Rick's Cancer
"Thanks for the update Robin. Keeping the two of you in my prayers. "
Sunday
Robin replied to Robin's discussion UPDATE On Things At My Home and my being absent! Ref: Rick's Cancer
"Thank you everyone for all your prayers. After a multitude of tests for 4 different doctors just to…"
Saturday
Duke posted a discussion

California

Looks like California is sliding further down the rabbit hole. Gov. Hairdo has signed a bill AB145…See More
Sep 24
Ed replied to Watchman's discussion 10 Reasons Why I Believe Trump Will Be Reelected
"Well thought out reasons. I too believe President Trump will be elected. My biggest concern perhaps…"
Sep 23
Jodi180 replied to Watchman's discussion 10 Reasons Why I Believe Trump Will Be Reelected
"All my fingers and toes...and eyes...are crossed, Watchman!"
Sep 22
Duke commented on J. Francis Roth's blog post FIND YOUR MANHOOD, AGAIN
"Never apoligize, it's a sign of weakness"
Sep 20
Lawrence Brown replied to Watchman's discussion 10 Reasons Why I Believe Trump Will Be Reelected
"Ten points are correct. We did not elect perfect man we elected a man who could fix our past…"
Sep 20
Jerseygal replied to Jerseygal's discussion History Is on the Side of Republicans Filling a Supreme Court Vacancy in 2020
"Worth reading the whole thing from the link.  It includes some charts to prove the points!"
Sep 19
Jerseygal posted discussions
Sep 19
Watchman replied to Watchman's discussion 10 Reasons Why I Believe Trump Will Be Reelected
"You're not alone. I've heard many Conservatives say the same exact thing. I debated about…"
Sep 19
kwicgov55 replied to Watchman's discussion 10 Reasons Why I Believe Trump Will Be Reelected
"All very good points Watchman! I did not vote for Trump in 2016, but have watched him and realize…"
Sep 19
kwicgov55 liked Watchman's discussion 10 Reasons Why I Believe Trump Will Be Reelected
Sep 19
kwicgov55 liked Jerseygal's discussion Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg dead at 87
Sep 19
kwicgov55 replied to Jerseygal's discussion Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg dead at 87
"I may not have agreed with her politics, but Ruth Bader Ginsberg was a fighter! She fought cancer…"
Sep 19
Watchman replied to Watchman's discussion 10 Reasons Why I Believe Trump Will Be Reelected
"I've heard about that and I wouldn't lie that it doesn't concern me a little. I…"
Sep 19
Watchman replied to Watchman's discussion 10 Reasons Why I Believe Trump Will Be Reelected
"I definitely think they are going to try and use voter fraud and contest the election in states…"
Sep 19

© 2020   Fundamental Refounding.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service