The Scarlet Zero- MACRA’s MIPS Completes Government Takeover of Medicine via @kksheld Please take 2 minutes to read.

Please take the time to read this article and share it with all of your contacts.

This was written by Dr. Kris Held, MD. I took this off of her Twitter timeline. Read it fully and help expose to everyone what is happening to our doctors, and, to the care we get as patients. Remember (The Death Panels)? Zeke Emanuel? 

What we all know from being active in this movement since Obama was elected is, everything we researched about Obamacare is truly the horrors we feared. It is happening, and, Dr. Held has been a voice for exposing this nightmare. 

The Scarlet Zero- MACRA’s MIPS Completes Government Takeover of Medicine

When Medicare and Medicaid were created, the government promised not to interfere in the practice of medicine whatsoever. President Lyndon Johnson signed the Act into law on July 30, 1965, ironically in Independence, MO. The Act established Medicare, a health insurance program for the elderly, and Medicaid, a health insurance program for the poor.


Nothing in this title shall be construed to authorize any Federal officer or employee to exercise any supervision or control over the practice of medicine or the manner in which medical services are provided, or over the selection, tenure, or compensation of any officer, or employee, or any institution, agency or person providing health care services… or to exercise any supervision or control over the administration or operation of any such [health-care] institution, agency, or person. Section 1801, Medicare Act, 1965


Fifty years later, in flagrant violation of this prohibition clause, stands the 2015 Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act (MACRA), replete with the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS). MIPS is a rubric the federal government uses to grade physicians and assign each a score of 0 to 100. The Composite Performance Score (CPS) is used to financially incentivize or penalize physicians, and then the scores are posted on a public website for all to see. I contend MIPS constitutes deliberate government extortion of our nation’s physician, and at the core lies the ultimate conflict of interest- the very lives and well-being of America’s patients vs. the money and power of the medico-industrial complex run by a small group of insider elites, implemented and micro managed by entrenched, faceless deep state bureaucrats. At the heart of the matter, begs the question of physicians, who do you serve? Are you a physician in the tradition of Hippocrates, who believed the physician works on behalf of the patient, not for the good of the state, or are you a physician like Plato, who urged that doctors refrain from curing the weak and infirm to improve society? Do you serve the patient or the state?


I further contend that implementing and complying with MIPS is ethically untenable for those who sacrifice and devote our lives to serving patients, and that physicians who do engage in MIPS either don’t understand it or are forsaking their virtue and morality under threat of bankruptcy and continued abuse from an over-aggressive government no longer controlled by the people but by a powerful cartel of self-serving third party bosses.


MIPS consists of four categories upon which physician are graded: quality (outcomes), advancing care information, improvement activities, and cost. Earning a high score often requires doing what government says instead of what is best for the patient. Doing what is best for the patient often results in a low score, loss of income, and public humiliation on the public website.


  1. While this sounds great, the “quality indicators” and “outcome measures” chosen may be harmful for patients or deter physicians from taking on the most difficult and challenging patients. For example, one measure of outcome is how many patients under a physicians’ care achieve a blood glucose level under a certain number. One of my patients told me she has passed out twice, sustaining injuries, since her PA put her on two diabetic medications to get her blood sugar below the government number. Imagine if she had been driving or been alone at home in her bathtub. She stopped taking the medications and has yet to return to her physician for care. Since I have refused to participate in MIPS and the likes, I am “out of network” for all insurance plans including Medicare and Medicaid. Ironically, I am seeing an influx of patients with what I call “3rd world cataracts” seeking my care. One that comes to mind could see light only when he sought my care. He is 60 years old with severe cardiovascular disease that presents a higher than normal surgical risk, but his quality of life is unnecessarily negatively impacted because he can only see light, not even hand motion. I did what was best for the patient, operated on him, and he is now 20/20. The surgery was more difficult, because in the government medicine shuffle with the risk of a poor outcome, he had been avoided by several surgeons trying to play the MIPS game to the point his cataracts were like granite rocks floating in bags of milk, making visibility and removal difficult. The physicians earning the highest “quality” or “outcomes” score might be inflicting undue danger on their patients or avoiding the most difficult, sickest, weakest patients altogether.
  2. Advancing Care Information (ACI). This used to be called “Meaningful Use Electronic Health Records”, but Advancing Care Information sounds so much friendlier that MACRA changed the term in Orwellian fashion. MACRA sets law and rules in motion that mandate that government have full, unblocked access to patients’ records, including their protected health information (PHI) without their permission. PHI includes all personal identifying data including all demographics and all medical history, past and present, including all medications ever taken. This is not just a violation of the Hippocratic Oath and sacrosanct patient-physician relationship, but this is a blatant violation of the 4th Amendment. Government will gather all data, not just MIPS data, on all patients, not just Medicare patients, and from all insurers- commercial too, not just Medicare. This data will be sold by government to entities the federal government itself chooses. On a personal note, when I was hospitalized after breast cancer surgery in 2012, an elderly male patient’s medication list was errantly entered into my electronic health record. Had I not been a physician, the error could have gone unnoticed, and I could have been severely injured if not killed. EHR’s have been implemented at warp speed without proper testing. Those seeking high MIPS scores facilitate this, thus, endangering patients and violating their rights. I believe it is my duty to keep my patients’ private information from government not transmit it to government.
  3. Improvement Activities. This is a sneaky one. This is a category where government hopes to, in their own words, “drive physician behavior,” like by having us engage in “education” activities that government deems important- like learning about the emerging “palliative care” movement, replete with educational material glorifying “aid in dying”- formerly know as “physician assisted suicide,” the little sister of euthanasia. This also links the Maintenance of Certification (MOC) issue to government scoring, and financial penalty or reward, and is the mechanism for control of physicians by hospitals, insurance companies, and groups working toward nationalized, if not international, medical licensure.
  4. Formerly known as Resource Use, this category is beyond worrisome. The sample grade chart itself shows that physicians who spend the most on their patients get 0 to 2 points while those that spend the least get 8 to 10 points. In other words, doctors get more money for withholding care and resources from patients and are penalized for delivering care and resources. Need I say more?


There can be no denying, MIPS is a top down, command and control grading system based on perverse incentives whereby government rewards physicians who do government bidding and penalizes physicians who serve their patients first. MIPS is more like a Marxist grading system used by China on their citizens than a grading system imposed on America’s physicians. Don’t shrug and think this doesn’t affect you. To make matters worse, government has redefined the definition of physician to include everyone from audiologists, dieticians, and speech pathologists to Nurse practitioners, Physicians Assistants, Nurse Midwives, clinical nurse specialists, psychologists, and so on. We are all now lumped into a group called “Eligible Clinicians” or “Eligible Professionals”- that subjects virtually everyone at all associated with health care to MACRA and its perverse MIPS. Read the law for yourself.


In the fifty years since Government vowed not to interfere with medicine whatsoever, government has completely taken us over. It is no wonder physician suicide is epidemic and life expectancy in the US is not increasing, but declining for the first time in history. Ask yourself; do you serve the patient or the state? Do not violate your oath, your ethics, and your conscience to get a higher Composite Performance Score and a positive payment modifier- AKA a payoff. I don’t know whether this is extortion, bribery or both, but I do know- I won’t do it. And neither should you. If physicians would not comply, this perverse system would die. Patients can help by understanding what is going on and realizing that physicians with the highest scores may not necessarily have their best interests in mind, while those of us who refuse to play this most dangerous game wear our Scarlet Zeroes proudly and deserve a second look rather than a premeditated shun.

Views: 73

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Back in the day, we all, or at least our parents were skeptical about government interference with health care and medicine.  If our parents were aware of the government corruption and how high up it actually went, we might not be in the shape we are today.  If they only knew what we know now.

OK, so I had to 'bing' MACRO...and found this site looks like a how-to for medical professionals. 


The MACRA Timeline

April 2015

Congress passed the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015.

April 2016

Department of Health and Human Services issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking for MACRA.

October 2016

CMS released the Final Rule which was published in the Federal Register on November 4, 2016.

January 2017

First Quality Payment Program Performance year begins.


Two Quality Payment Program (QPP) Pathways

The stated purpose of MACRA’s Quality Payment Program (QPP) is to provide new tools and resources to help give patients the best possible, highest-value care. It is intended to initially transform the Medicare payment structure, while moving towards a larger scope to eventually include the entire healthcare continuum and broader payer system.

Merit-Based Incentive System (MIPS)

Replaces the PQRS, EHR Meaningful Use and Value-Based Modifier Programs

Advanced Alternative Payment Models (AAPMs)

Subset of APMs which provides incentives for High-Quality and Cost-Effective Care

I did notice a graph under the Merit-Based Incentive System that shows Future MIPS Reporting Rates.  I'm assuming that years after 2019 will continue on a disturbing trend.

How is it that this will "give patients the best possible, highest-value care" when cost becomes more important than quality of care?

Are there any “Eligible Clinicians” or “Eligible Professionals” on this site that can comment?

Hi Jodi! 

I follow Dr. Held on twitter @kksheld and, she has been warning and writing about all of this for awhile.  We have spoken on and off. She has refused to participate in Macra and Mips to her own detriment. She refuses to not do what is right and what is best for her patients, just to get a high score from the government. They have now made her "out of network" on all insurances because of her choice to put patients first. That's why the title of her article is The Scarlet Zero! 

Check out her twitter timeline! She's awesome.

Kris Held,MD Retweeted JT Badenov

This is why we must fight Socialized medicine in the US.

Kris Held,MD added,

Dr. Held is the best. She is a very strong voice against what Obamacare has done to the medical field, doctors and patients. 





Please view our mission, policy, and legal disclaimer to learn about us by visiting the main menu.  Thank you.


AGENDA 21/2030 


Let your voice be counted!








national debt

Founders' Corner

Latest Activity

JeansBrother replied to Lynn Rackoski's discussion Some Lawmakers Ask Capitol to Withhold Pay Until Shutdown Ends, Citing Military, DACA
"Each member of the sitting Congress should be fined 50% of his/her annual salary each time they do…"
56 minutes ago
JeansBrother replied to Robin's discussion MAGA: Mexico Loses Chrysler Car Plant and Jobs to Americans
"I guess there is more than one way Mexico will pay for the wall."
1 hour ago
JeansBrother replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion Speaker Ryan... Government Shutdown #SchumerShutdown
"So, leave the government shut down until the democrat senators cry uncle and ask for it to be…"
1 hour ago
JeansBrother replied to Robin's discussion Fusion GPS and the ‘Insurance Policy’ to Prevent Trump From Becoming President... A graphic showing the web of connections related to the Trump dossier
"The chart shows multisourcing of the same document to Comey which helps him claim deniability in…"
1 hour ago
Jerome replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion GOP lawmakers demand that 'alarming' memo on FISA abuses be made public #ReleaseTheMemo
"I wouldn't be surprised when this report is made public, only the 2 & 3 letter words i.e.,…"
3 hours ago
DebE replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion GOP lawmakers demand that 'alarming' memo on FISA abuses be made public #ReleaseTheMemo
"Rep. Joyce said it could take "up to 19 Congressional work days."  By my estimates…"
15 hours ago
DebE liked Fundamental Refounding's discussion GOP lawmakers demand that 'alarming' memo on FISA abuses be made public #ReleaseTheMemo
15 hours ago
Lynn Rackoski posted discussions
16 hours ago
Lynn Rackoski replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion GOP lawmakers demand that 'alarming' memo on FISA abuses be made public #ReleaseTheMemo
"The Memo is going to be released! @RepDaveJoyce Great news! Our efforts to #ReleaseTheMemo have…"
16 hours ago
Fundamental Refounding posted discussions
17 hours ago
Fundamental Refounding replied to Robin's discussion MAGA: Mexico Loses Chrysler Car Plant and Jobs to Americans
"Trump has created over 2.2 Million jobs so far. "
17 hours ago
Fundamental Refounding replied to Jodi180's discussion Peter Stzrok: 'This is horribly wrong'
"Fusion GPS and the ‘Insurance Policy’ to Prevent Trump From Becoming President... A…"
17 hours ago
Fundamental Refounding replied to Robin's discussion Trump's Decision To Cut UNRWA Funding Is The First Step Toward Middle East Peace
"Cut ALL funds to the UN! "
17 hours ago
Robin posted a discussion
17 hours ago
Robin posted photos
17 hours ago
Griswold liked Lynn Rackoski's discussion A TIMELINE OF TREASON: How the DNC and FBI Leadership Tried to Fix a Presidential Election
19 hours ago


© 2018   Fundamental Refounding.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service