Judicial Watch received DOJ “Vaughn index” ..Obama Asserted #FastandFurious Executive Privilege Claim for Holder’s Wife

Judicial Watch announced today that it received from the Obama Department of Justice (DOJ) a “Vaughn index” detailing records about the Operation Fast and Furious scandal. The index was forced out of the Obama administration thanks to JW’s June 2012 Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request and subsequent September 2012 FOIA lawsuit (Judicial Watch v. Department of Justice (No. 1:12-cv-01510)). A federal court had ordered the production over the objections of the Obama Justice Department.

The document details the Attorney General Holder’s personal involvement in managing the Justice Department’s strategy on media and Congressional investigations into the Fast and Furious scandal. Notably, the document discloses that emails between Attorney General Holder and his wife Sharon Malone – as well as his mother – are being withheld under an extraordinary claim of executive privilege as well as a dubious claim of deliberative process privilege under the Freedom of Information Act. The “First Lady of the Justice Department” is a physician and not a government employee.

This is the first time that the Obama administration has provided a detailed listing of all records being withheld from Congress and the American people about the deadly Fast and Furious gun running scandal. The 1307-page “draft” Vaughn index was emailed to Judicial Watch at 8:34 p.m. last night, a few hours before a federal court-ordered deadline. In its cover letter, the Department of Justice asserts that all of the responsive records described in the index are “subject to the assertion of executive privilege.”

The Vaughn index explains 15,662 documents. Typically, a Vaughn index must: (1) identify each record withheld; (2) state the statutory exemption claimed; and (3) explain how disclosure would damage the interests protected by the claimed exemption. The Vaughn index arguably fails to provide all of this required information but does provide plenty of interesting information for a public kept in the dark for years about the Fast and Furious scandal.

Based on a preliminary review of the massive document, Judicial Watch can disclose that the Vaughn index reveals:

Numerous emails that detail Attorney General Holder’s direct involvement in crafting talking points, the timing of public disclosures, and handling Congressional inquiries in the Fast and Furious matter.
President Obama has asserted executive privilege over nearly 20 email communications between Holder and his spouse Sharon Malone. The administration also claims that the records are also subject to withholding under the “deliberative process” exemption. This exemption ordinarily exempts from public disclosure records that could chill internal government deliberations.
Numerous entries detail DOJ’s communications (including those of Eric Holder) concerning the White House about Fast and Furious.
The scandal required the attention of virtually every top official of the DOJ and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF). Communications to and from the United States Ambassador to Mexico about the Fast and Furious matter are also described.
Many of the records are already publicly available such as letters from Congress, press clips, and typical agency communications. Ordinarily, these records would, in whole or part, be subject to disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act. Few of the records seem to even implicate presidential decision-making and advice that might be subject to President Obama’s broad and unprecedented executive privilege claim.
Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton criticized President Obama and his disgraced Attorney General in a statement today:

This document provides key information about the cover-up of Fast and Furious by Attorney General Eric Holder and other high-level officials of the Obama administration. Obama’s executive privilege claims over these records are a fraud and an abuse of his office. There is no precedent for President Obama’s Nixonian assertion of executive privilege over these ordinary government agency records. Americans will be astonished that Obama asserted executive privilege over Eric Holder’s emails to his wife about Fast and Furious.

Once again, Judicial Watch has proven itself more effective than Congress and the establishment media in providing basic oversight of this out-of-control Administration. This Fast and Furious document provides dozens of leads for further congressional, media, and even criminal investigations.

On June 28, 2012, Attorney General Eric Holder was held in contempt by the House of Representatives over his refusal to turn over records explaining why the Obama administration may have lied to Congress and refused for months to disclose the truth about the gun running operation. It marked the first time in U.S. history that a sitting Attorney General was held in contempt of Congress.

A week before the contempt finding, to protect Holder from criminal prosecution and stave off the contempt vote, President Obama asserted executive privilege over the Fast and Furious records the House Oversight Committee had subpoenaed eight months earlier. Judicial Watch filed its FOIA request two days later. Holder’s Justice Department wouldn’t budge (or follow the law), so JW filed a FOIA lawsuit on September 12, 2012.

But then the Justice Department convinced U.S. District Court Judge John D. Bates to stay our lawsuit, in part to allow ongoing settlement discussions between the Holder’s government lawyers and the House Committee to continue. Unsurprisingly, the “negotiations” between politicians running the House and the Justice Department went nowhere.

Fed up with the interminable delay caused Holder’s gamesmanship and stonewalling, JW renewed its request to the Court to allow our transparency lawsuit to continue. Thankfully, this past July, Judge John D. Bates ended the 16-month delay and ordered the Obama administration to produce a Vaughn index of the alleged “executive privilege” records by October 1. Judge Bates noted that no court has ever “expressly recognized” President Obama’s unprecedented executive privilege claims in the Fast and Furious matter.

Unhappy with having to produce the records prior to the elections, Justice lawyers asked the judge to give them one extra month, until November 3 (the day before Election Day!) to produce the info. Judge Bates rejected this gambit, suggested that the Holder’s agency did not take court order seriously. Rather than a month, Judge Bates gave Justice until yesterday to cough up the Vaughn index. Judge Bates issued his smack down on September 23.

Attorney General Eric Holder announced his resignation two days later.

Many share our opinion it was “no coincidence” that Holder’s resignation came “on the heels of another court ruling that the Justice Department must finally cough up information about how Holder’s Justice Department lied to Congress and the American people about the Operation Fast and Furious scandal, for which Eric Holder was held in contempt by the House of Representatives.”

The House had been separately litigating to obtain the records but had gotten nowhere until after Judge Bates ruled that the DOJ finally had to disclose information to Judicial Watch.

On September 9, U.S. District Court Judge Amy Berman Jackson, citing Judicial Watch’s success, ordered the Justice Department to produce information to Congress by November 3.

Fast and Furious was a DOJ/Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) “gun running” operation in which the Obama administration reportedly allowed guns to go to Mexican drug cartels hoping they would end up at crime scenes, advancing gun-control policies. Fast and Furious weapons have been implicated in the murder of Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry and hundreds of other innocents in Mexico. Guns from the Fast and Furious scandal are expected to be used in criminal activity on both sides of the U.S.-Mexico border for years to come.

Guns from the Fast and Furious scandal continue to be used in crimes. Just last week, Judicial Watch disclosed that a Fast and Furious gun was used in gang -style assault on a Phoenix apartment building that left two people wounded. We figured this out from information we uncovered through another public records lawsuit against the City of Phoenix.

Congress officially confirmed the AK-47 was used in the assault that terrorized residents in Phoenix. In an October 16 letter sent from Sen. Charles Grassley (R-IA) and Rep. Darryl Issa (R-CA) to Deputy Attorney General James Cole discloses that “we have learned of another crime gun connected to Fast and Furious. The [Justice] Department did not provide any notice to the Congress or the public about this gun….This lack of transparency about the consequences of Fast and Furious undermines public confidence in law enforcement and gives the impression that the Department is seeking to suppress information and limit its exposure to public scrutiny.”

http://www.judicialwatch.org/blog/2014/10/obama-asserts-fast-furiou...

Views: 41

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

This is one of the many scandals that we cannot allow to be swept under the rug! None of them should have executive privilege to cover up getting people killed, and Holder's wife especially shouldn't be granted it!

I agree JG.  I never gave Holder permission to kill over 300 Mexicans.  And that was the number ... when people stopped counting.  I have no idea what it is now.  And when Holder and others speak of gun control, they leave out that the biggest deaths are sometimes due to the government:

  • 300 dead or more in Fast and Furious
  • 80 dead in the massacre at Waco
  • 200 armed US marshals with assault rifles to talk to farmers about a cattle dispute ????

I as one citizen, never ever gave a politician the authority to be a serial killer

Thanks!  It's good we have JW!

Surprise, Surprise, Surprise!  Valerie Jarrett Key Player in Fast and Furious Cover-Up After Holder Lied to Congress!

President Obama’s trusted senior advisor, Valerie Jarrett, was a key player in the effort to cover up that Attorney General Eric Holder lied to Congress about the Fast and Furious scandal, according to public records obtained by Judicial Watch.

The information is part of a Department of Justice (DOJ) “Vaughn index” detailing records about the gun-running operation known as Fast and Furious. JW had to sue the agency for the records after the Obama administration failed to provide them under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). A federal court ordered the DOJ to provide the records over the agency’s objections. Yesterday JW reported on the broad information in the records, including that Obama asserted executive privilege for Holder’s wife as part of the administration’s efforts to cover up the scandal.

Practically lost in the 1,000-plus pages of records is an index that shows Jarrett was brought in to manage the fact that Holder lied to Congress after the story about the disastrous gun-running operation broke in the media. The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco Firearms and Explosives (ATF) ran the once-secret program that allowed guns from the U.S. to be smuggled into Mexico so they could eventually be traced to drug cartels. Instead, federal law enforcement officers lost track of hundreds of weapons which have been used in an unknown number of crimes, including the murder of a U.S. Border Patrol agent in Arizona.

The files received by JW include three electronic mails between Holder and Jarrett and one from former U.S. Attorney Dennis Burke to Jarrett. The e-mails with Holder are all from October 4, 2011, a significant date because, on the evening of October 3rd, Sheryl Attkisson (then at CBS news) released documents showing that Holder had been sent a briefing paper on Operation Fast and Furious on June 5, 2010. The paper was from the director of the National Drug Intelligence Center, Michael Walther.

This directly contradicted Holder’s May 3, 2011 testimony to the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, during which he stated that he, “probably heard about Fast and Furious for the first time over the last few weeks.” The October 4, 2011 date may also be significant because it came shortly after the August 30, 2011 resignation of U.S. Attorney for Arizona Dennis Burke and reassignment of acting ATF director Kenneth Melson to the position of “senior forensics advisor” at DOJ.

The description of one of the e-mails, written from Jarrett to Holder, reads, “re: personnel issues.” Another, also from Jarrett, reads, “outlining and discussing preferred course of action for future responses in light of recent development in congressional investigation.” Unfortunately, the index is vague and that’s all the information we have about them. Nevertheless, given the timing and subject of these e-mails, it seems clear that Jarrett quickly became a key player in the Fast and Furious cover-up in the immediate aftermath of the revelation that Holder had lied to Congress.

http://www.judicialwatch.org/blog/2014/10/valerie-jarrett-key-playe...

RSS

Attention:

 

 

Please view our mission, policy, and legal disclaimer to learn about us by visiting the main menu.  Thank you.

PLEASE SIGN THE PETITION!

BRING BACK #HUAC

http://bit.ly/2mqIVmH 

CONTACT CONGRESS!

Let your voice be counted!

House:  http://1.usa.gov/mHZjgo

Senate:  http://1.usa.gov/3UAs

 

 

PLEASE PRAY FOR OUR NATION.

 

 

national debt

Founders' Corner

Latest Activity

kwicgov55 replied to Robin's discussion Wed Tids 12/2/20 TOP TID It’s Time for Republicans to Reimagine and Reinvent Themselves
"I didn't think anything could shock me when it came to the corruption involved in politics,…"
21 hours ago
kwicgov55 liked Robin's discussion Wed Tids 12/2/20 TOP TID It’s Time for Republicans to Reimagine and Reinvent Themselves
21 hours ago
Jodi180 replied to Jodi180's discussion Stolen Election? If So, Can It Be "Unstolen"?
"Time to get noisy with our 'representatives'.  Thanks to Rep. Brooks. Mo Brooks to…"
yesterday
Ruthann replied to Robin's discussion UPDATE 12/2/2020 On Things At My Home and my being absent! Ref: Rick's Cancer
"I'll be Praying for the both of you and asking God for a Miracle to help Rick. "
yesterday
Robin replied to Robin's discussion UPDATE On Things At My Home and my being absent! Ref: Rick's Cancer
"Update! Sorry for such an absence!! The surgery that was scheduled had to be cancelled. He was all…"
yesterday
Robin posted discussions
yesterday
Robin replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion #Agenda21 /2030 Tids 6/27/17 TOP TID Here is the true danger that we face.
"THIS truly Is the reason that we are living this nightmare! This agenda is the reason for…"
yesterday
Robin replied to Doug Fox's discussion Traitors Justice II
"Catherine Herridge @CBS_Herridge · Dec 1 BREAKING #Durham This is a major development +…"
yesterday
Robin replied to Jodi180's discussion Stolen Election? If So, Can It Be "Unstolen"?
"Col. Waldron Confirms US Has a Copy of the Election Night Data ‘Traffic and Packets’…"
yesterday
Robin replied to Doug Fox's discussion Traitors Justice II
"OH MY GAWD,DOUG! I can NOT wait for EVERYTHING to come out! Our government and the left, are SATAN!…"
yesterday
Robin replied to Jodi180's discussion Stolen Election? If So, Can It Be "Unstolen"?
"Absolutely Stolen Election! I believe from everything I have seen, this election will be…"
yesterday
Robin replied to Robin's discussion PROJECT VERITAS! @JamesOKeefeIII .. We've been recording @CNN 9AM call for MONTHS and we are going to start releasing the tapes!
"James O'Keefe @JamesOKeefeIII · 1h CNN: Let’s attack Trump’s kids over…"
yesterday
Robin replied to Robin's discussion PROJECT VERITAS! @JamesOKeefeIII .. We've been recording @CNN 9AM call for MONTHS and we are going to start releasing the tapes!
"NEW CNN TAPE: @CNN Senior Vice President @cynthiacnn Demeans Marginalized Community; States…"
yesterday
Robin replied to Robin's discussion PROJECT VERITAS! @JamesOKeefeIII .. We've been recording @CNN 9AM call for MONTHS and we are going to start releasing the tapes!
"James O'Keefe @JamesOKeefeIII · 3h BREAKING: @CNN Execs Jeff Zucker, David Chalian,…"
yesterday
Jodi180 posted a discussion

Stolen Election? If So, Can It Be

So I found this in a comment section of an article about Sidney Powell:…See More
Nov 16
Duke posted a discussion

Corrupt Election

From some AZ lawyers,Ok, in a nut shell, this is going to the Supreme Court. Where they will rule…See More
Nov 13

© 2020   Fundamental Refounding.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service