This situation clearly has two sides - does the church have a First Amendment right to use the structure for worship, or does the village have the right to say what entity can operate in its various ‘zones?’   Surely the church would seek non-profit status for at least a portion of the real estate tax, which means that the village would lose all or part of that tax revenue.  I’d love to see some discussions!  Patriots, please weigh in!

CFC back before Canton village Zoning Board of Appeals over using 25 Court Street for offices
Thursday, February 21, 2019 - 5:18 pm

By ADAM ATKINSON
North Country This Week

CANTON – The village Zoning Board of Appeals will convene Monday, March 4 at 7 p.m. in the village courtroom, 61 Main St., to discuss and possibly act on request by the Christian Fellowship Center to use the property at 25 Court St. for professional office space.

The church was denied an office space use permit by code enforcer Jeffrey Murray in January. Murray’s denial is based on village zoning code which does not allow churches or religious organizations in the municipality’s C1 commercial zone where the property is located.

The CFC has recently launched a lawsuit against the village over the denial of a use permit to hold religious services at the 25 Court St. building formerly known as The Club restaurant. A denial of that use permit was handed down by Murray for the same zoning reason in January and subsequently upheld by the ZBA when the church asked them for a reinterpretation of village code.

The village is represented by Clifton Park attorney Gregg Johnson of Johnson & Laws LLC. Chicago legal firm Mauck & Baker LLC is representing the CFC in the matter.

Read more about the firms here.

The CFC bought the property for $310,000 at the beginning of January without securing any kind of use permit for the site and before receiving the ZBA’s decision. The ZBA’s support of Murray’s first denial was based on the village zoning code and the determination under federal Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act that the church was not being treated as less than equal to another organization or individual seeking use permits in the village.

The ZBA’s deliberations pointed out that other organizations and persons would also have to follow established village zoning laws to obtain use permits.

The C1 zone is a relatively compact area in the village’s downtown business district and was set up seemingly to concentrate commercial businesses in one area. Several other zones in the village do allow churches and religious organizations

http://northcountrynow.com/news/cfc-back-canton-village-zoning-boar...

Views: 48

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Not really enough info to form an opinion on. Could be limitations thru zoning due to parking issues or any number of other reasons. If the zoning board reasoning is because it's a religious institution operating in town, well that's different problem. 

Doug, I am not sure if Zoning Hearing Board transcripts are available.  I’ve argued both sides of this in my head for days - winters are long here LOL!

  • Church purchased the property without securing that use permit, or maybe without learning that they needed one in the first place. Caveat emptor, right?
  • The village has several churches in the immediate area, but on other streets ...literally around the corner or, in the opposite direction, up the street.
  • The building in question has some parking, but I don’t remember how much-  I attended numerous political ‘meet and greet’ events there when it was a restaurant.
  • I believe a municipality has the right to plan for its own future, in terms of growth and development, keeping in mind that such plans must not be discriminatory (like how do you allow an art gallery but not a tattoo parlor?)
  • I also believe that a municipality should respect individual property rights, and not act as regimented HOA

Any additional pros or cons with the info at hand?

Not quite sure on this. I know here it all comes down to zoning. When we got this property, it was zoned commercial. In order for us to build our house, we had to go before the zoning board and sign paperwork that we would not operate a business out of here. They then switched it to residential, but, the zoning board needed papers signed from us as well. This property was used for a business since 1976.

Robin, I see the benefits of zoning laws.  I was actually involved with planning and zoning.  I google-mapped this for you, Native.  I know the town as well.....this will help you all understand why it can be confusing, and lead some to believe that a First Amendment violation exists.  I marked the property in question with a red blob.

What isn’t shown are the numerous shops, restaurants, pizzerias, insurance offices, banks, locksmith, liquor store......all in within a 3 minute walk.

I'm getting what you're saying about it now. I believe it could be a violation of the 1st amendment. especially with other churches in close proximity and all the other things around it.

This sounds like a zoning issue, not a 1st. amendment right issue. 

......unless zoning laws violate the First Amendment....

Hmm, that is something to think about.

RSS

Attention:

 

 

Please view our mission, policy, and legal disclaimer to learn about us by visiting the main menu.  Thank you.

PLEASE SIGN THE PETITION!

BRING BACK #HUAC

http://bit.ly/2mqIVmH 

CONTACT CONGRESS!

Let your voice be counted!

House:  http://1.usa.gov/mHZjgo

Senate:  http://1.usa.gov/3UAs

 

 

PLEASE PRAY FOR OUR NATION.

 

 

national debt

Founders' Corner

Latest Activity

J. Francis Roth replied to Lynn Rackoski's discussion Why Kamala Harris VP pick could cost Biden the election....
"It's a pretty pathetic thought when one has to attribute a huge loss for Biden to the…"
8 hours ago
Doug Fox replied to Doug Fox's discussion Traitor's Justice
"The first indictment, of which I am hoping leads to…"
10 hours ago
J. Francis Roth replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion Wed Tids 7/29/20 TOP TID We're Seeing the Death Rattle of the Revolution, Not Its Birth
"Look around your neighborhood elementary and high schools.  Ask a teacher you can trust if…"
11 hours ago
Jodi180 replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion Wed Tids 7/29/20 TOP TID We're Seeing the Death Rattle of the Revolution, Not Its Birth
"Case in point: Ibram Kendi's Board Book Teaches Even Babies To Hate White PeopleThere's…"
11 hours ago
J. Francis Roth replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion Wed Tids 7/29/20 TOP TID We're Seeing the Death Rattle of the Revolution, Not Its Birth
"It doesn't end.  America has already graduated hundreds of thousands of indoctrinated,…"
15 hours ago
Lynn Rackoski posted a discussion

Why Kamala Harris VP pick could cost Biden the election....

Why Kamala Harris VP pick could cost Biden the electionThe only person who should be happier with…See More
yesterday
Susan Taylor posted a discussion

Trump Goes After FBI Director Wray for ‘protecting’ Russia probe ‘gang’

Wray needs to go!Trump takes swipe at FBI Director Wray for ‘protecting’ Russia probe…See More
yesterday
Robin replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion Wed Tids 7/29/20 TOP TID We're Seeing the Death Rattle of the Revolution, Not Its Birth
"I agree with you Jodi. We are really up against a massive indoctrination operation that has been…"
yesterday
Robin liked Fundamental Refounding's discussion Wed Tids 7/29/20 TOP TID We're Seeing the Death Rattle of the Revolution, Not Its Birth
yesterday
Robin replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion Trump Touts ‘Suburban Lifestyle Dream’ After Rescinding Obama-Era Rule Preventing Housing Discrimination
"I was so pleased to see this too, Jodi! Huge win!"
yesterday
Robin liked Fundamental Refounding's discussion Trump Touts ‘Suburban Lifestyle Dream’ After Rescinding Obama-Era Rule Preventing Housing Discrimination
yesterday
Robin posted a discussion

Trump Announces 'Historic Peace Agreement' Between Israel, UAE

Trump announces 'Historic Peace Agreement' between Israel, UAEUnited Arab Emirates and Israel agree…See More
yesterday
Jodi180 replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion Wed Tids 7/29/20 TOP TID We're Seeing the Death Rattle of the Revolution, Not Its Birth
"I agree with your post, J.  The 'Revolution' to destroy America has been ongoing…"
Wednesday
Jodi180 replied to Fundamental Refounding's discussion Trump Touts ‘Suburban Lifestyle Dream’ After Rescinding Obama-Era Rule Preventing Housing Discrimination
"This is such good news! As Tome DeWeese of the American Policy Center writes: First, as I reported…"
Wednesday
J. Francis Roth updated their profile
Aug 7
Nicole Johnston liked Jodi180's discussion No One's Coming to Save America...We Must Save Ourselves
Aug 6

© 2020   Fundamental Refounding.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service